Close Menu
DemocracyGuyana.comDemocracyGuyana.com

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest news from DemocracyGuyana.com

    What's Hot

    A Word of Caution to Young Professionals

    July 31, 2025

    In the homestretch of elections 2025, the PPP stares at a landslide victory

    July 31, 2025

    Weaponizing 0.019% of votes to rewrite history? That’s not legal reasoning-it’s political theatre.

    July 30, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • About DG
    • Join as Volunteers
    • Become a Member
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube TikTok
    DemocracyGuyana.comDemocracyGuyana.com
    Jet Global Airways
    • Home
    • Diaspora
    • Guyana News
    • Global News
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Business Opportunities
    • Advertise with us
    • Photo Gallery
    • Videos
    • World Newspapers
    • Contact Us
    DemocracyGuyana.comDemocracyGuyana.com
    Home»Featured»Re: Dr. Thomas Singh’s Economic Theory in Reverse Order
    Featured

    Re: Dr. Thomas Singh’s Economic Theory in Reverse Order

    Joel BhagwandinBy Joel BhagwandinNo Comments4 Mins Read431 Views
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Telegram Tumblr Email
    Joel Bhagwandin
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Reference is made to Dr. Thomas B. Singh’s letter in the Stabroek News edition of June 11, 2024, with the caption “the BOG policy seems to be a pursuit of exchange rate targeting as against inflation targeting or price stability”. In the said letter, the author concluded by inviting “commentators, and especially those who only care about politics, would add to the discussion in a meaningful way”.

    While this authoris inclined to add to the discussion in a meaningful way, there is nothing meaningful to add or even counter Dr. Singh’s contention, because his argument which ordinarily rests on elementary economic theory, is fundamentally wrong.

    Dr. Singh contends that (i) the central bank is more concerned about exchange rate targeting and not inflation rate targeting. Dr. Singh, who is a trained economist forgets that inflation rate is linked to exchange rate especially in the case of Guyana since we import ≥90% of the goods we consume, intermediate goods and capital goods. It therefore means that bymanaging the exchange rate, the inflation rate is also being taken care of.And (ii) he argued that we should allow the exchange rate to appreciate to increase exports. But this is another fundamental error on the part of Dr. Singh. Export competitiveness is more linked to exchange rate depreciation, not appreciation. An appreciation of the exchange rate will in fact make exports more expensive and imports cheaper, thus inflationary.

    On the other hand, exchange rate depreciation would make exports cheaper, hence more internationally competitive. This was one of the main reasons why we had exchange rate devaluation in the 1990s and early 2000s.It was part of the economic recovery programme when the country was bankrupt, to generate foreign exchange earnings through exports.

    The table below statistically demonstrate the foregoing explanation.

    Source: Bank of Guyana Statistical Abstract

    As shown in the table above, non-oil exports in 2023 amounted to US$1.546 billion, while non-oil imports amounted to US$4.589 billion, thereby giving rise to a non-oil trade balance deficit of US$3 billion. At an appreciated exchange rate of G$200/US$1, non-oil exports equate to G$309.2 billion, non-oil imports would equate to G$917.8 billion, with a trade balance deficit amounting to G$608.6 billion. Conversely, at a depreciated exchange rate of G$215/US$1, non-oil exports would equate to G$332.4 billion, non-oil imports would equate to G$986.6 billion, and the trade balance deficit would equate to G$654.2 billion.

    As can be seen, the same value of imports in USD, would cost the Guyanese consumers G$68.8 billion more at an exchange rate of $215, up from $200, which would be inflationary. In contrast, exports will become more expensive for the consumers in the exporting country because that country will essentially be paying more USD to purchase Guyanese exports. Consequently, exports would become less competitive, which could result into a decline in exports value. And this is what we have to guard against, whereby any sharp appreciation in the exchange rate would engender what is commonly known as the dreaded “Dutch disease”.

    In the final analysis, Dr. Singh has the theory mixed up (in reverse order), which renders his argument contradictory. The Central Bank would have great difficulty controlling inflation rate if the exchange rate is allowed to appreciate too sharply. In this situation, it would mean that the bottled water that is imported from Trinidad and Tobago, for example, would become far cheaper than the bottled water produced right here in Guyana by Banks DIH and DDL. So, which one do you think the Guyanese consumers would prefer, and what will become of the local producers, whose products would then become less competitive because of an appreciated exchange rate? Dr. Thomas Singh, please explain!

    Featured Top Right
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Joel Bhagwandin
    Joel Bhagwandin

    Related Posts

    A Word of Caution to Young Professionals

    In the homestretch of elections 2025, the PPP stares at a landslide victory

    Weaponizing 0.019% of votes to rewrite history? That’s not legal reasoning-it’s political theatre.

    WIN will lose the election because of its manifesto

    Juretha Fernandes, a picture of Machiavellianism

    The Biggest Idiot and Buffoon That Guyana Has Produced: A National Warning Against Azruddin Mohamed by U.S. Law Authorities.

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    What do you make of it? by Leonard Craig

    November 18, 2024744K Views

    President Irfaan Ali Emphasises Discipline and Accountability Over Project Delays

    November 13, 2024566K Views

    The Hollow Ambitions of Nigel Hughes: A Political Opportunist and Exhibitionist with Empty Promises.

    July 11, 2024100K Views
    Don't Miss

    A Word of Caution to Young Professionals

    Since the submission and approval of the list of candidates for the upcoming elections, I’ve…

    In the homestretch of elections 2025, the PPP stares at a landslide victory

    July 31, 2025

    Weaponizing 0.019% of votes to rewrite history? That’s not legal reasoning-it’s political theatre.

    July 30, 2025

    WIN will lose the election because of its manifesto

    July 30, 2025
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews
    72

    Over 50 poisoned at wedding in Iraq

    8.9

    EAM Jaishankar Meets Guyanese PM Mark Phillips, Discuss Energy, Disaster Resilience And Defence Cooperation

    Most Popular

    What do you make of it? by Leonard Craig

    November 18, 2024744K Views

    President Irfaan Ali Emphasises Discipline and Accountability Over Project Delays

    November 13, 2024566K Views

    The Hollow Ambitions of Nigel Hughes: A Political Opportunist and Exhibitionist with Empty Promises.

    July 11, 2024100K Views
    Our Picks

    A Word of Caution to Young Professionals

    July 31, 2025

    In the homestretch of elections 2025, the PPP stares at a landslide victory

    July 31, 2025

    Weaponizing 0.019% of votes to rewrite history? That’s not legal reasoning-it’s political theatre.

    July 30, 2025
    Popular Categories
    • Global News
    • Election Rigging
    • Sports
    • Special News
    Do you want to associate with us
    • Business Opportunities
    • Advertise with us
    • Contact Us
    • www.democracyguyana.com Guyana – London – India

      For more information, contact us.
    DemocracyGuyana.com
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube TikTok
    • Home
    • About DG
    • Become a Member
    • Join as Volunteers
    • Forum
    • Advertise with us
    DG BRANCHES: GUYANA, USA, CANADA, UK, CARIBBEAN, AND INDIA
    © 2025 DemocracyGuyana.com.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.