Close Menu
DemocracyGuyana.comDemocracyGuyana.com

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest news from DemocracyGuyana.com

    What's Hot

    Do Guyanese truly want to vote for these Opposition Presidential Candidates — Aubrey Norton, Nigel Hughes, Amanza Walton-Desir, and Azruddin Mohamed — None presents a real vision, a concrete economic plan, or a sense of national unity. What they offer is a Coalition of Chaos — built on race-baiting, fraud, and political irrelevance.

    June 21, 2025

    NONSENSE THAT PPP CALLED ELECTIONS EARLY GIVING THEMSELVES UNFAIR ADVANTAGE

    June 21, 2025

    The PNCR and the women in the party

    June 21, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • About DG
    • Join as Volunteers
    • Become a Member
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube TikTok
    DemocracyGuyana.comDemocracyGuyana.com
    Jet Global Airways
    • Home
    • Diaspora
    • Guyana News
    • Global News
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Business Opportunities
    • Advertise with us
    • Photo Gallery
    • Videos
    • World Newspapers
    • Contact Us
    DemocracyGuyana.comDemocracyGuyana.com
    Home»Featured»Incoherent Opinionated Ramblings Cannot Supplant Rigorous Empirical Analysis
    Featured

    Incoherent Opinionated Ramblings Cannot Supplant Rigorous Empirical Analysis

    Joel BhagwandinBy Joel BhagwandinNo Comments5 Mins Read93 Views
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Telegram Tumblr Email
    Joel Bhagwandin
    Joel Bhagwandin
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    In a four-part series of op-ed articles, Ret’d Rear Admiral Dr. Gary Best (hereinafter “the author”) attempted to critically analyze the national budget for the fiscal year 2024 (hereinafter “budget 2024”), but ineptly failed to provide any meaningful critical contribution. Instead, his series were fraught with incoherent, unjustified opinionated ramblings, as demonstrated hereunder.

    In part 1, the author contends that…the budget has no clear structure that points to medium or long-term certainty… no clear policy statements to indicate that the budgets are linked to indexed values…the budget is not set within any long term nationally ‘agreed to’ strategic and national development plan…there is no coherent overarching plan…the government is not engaged in any careful conception and analysis, any careful planning to what a budget really means…”. Ironically, the author failed to substantiate his “aspersions” noted above in a coherent and robustly analytical manner, the very precepts that he accused the government of failing to perform.

    The notion that there is no coherent overarching national development plan is factually incorrect. The PPP/C Government first developed a “National Development Plan” in 1994-1996, with the involvement of more than 200 Guyanese stakeholders, including civil society, private sector, and professionals from across various spheres. The incremental implementation of that strategy commenced almost immediately after it was finalized in 1996, through every national budget from 1997-2014 and from 2020 to present. This is easily verifiable by examining all of the national budgets for those years in tandem with the National Development Strategy, 1996, that part of which can be obtained from the internet. For example, all of the road networks, highways, bridges including the new bridge across the Demerara River, a secondary city more inland (Silica City), the road network connecting Brazil/Guyana, and a feasibility study for the reintroduction of railways, just to name a few―are all contained in that strategy that was developed nearly three decades ago. This strategy was then followed by the “Poverty Reduction Strategy”, the “National Competitiveness Strategy”, the “Low Carbon Development Strategy” (LCDS) (2009 version), and the current updated and expanded version of the LCDS (2030). 

    With this in mind, the author who presented himself as a scholarly authority on these matters, would have had to firstly acknowledge that the aforementioned strategies exist, which he is fully-well aware of, but chose to ignore. The author’s hastened exhibition of intentional ignorance cannot repudiate the established fact that the aforesaid national strategies are in existence.

    Secondly, assuming that the author is a credible scholar of some calibre, the author would have then had to skillfully establish that budget 2024, together with previous years PPP/C Government budgets, consistently deviated from their own national development framework. Unfortunately, the author failed disastrously at so doing. If at all, there were any underlying merit and factual basis for the author’s aspersions; had he done so, he would have been able to easily, and systematically illustrate his case with irrefutable empiricism.

    Thirdly, if the author is implying that the aforementioned national development strategies are not coherent overarching development plans and strategies, according to him, then the burden is upon him to intelligibly validate such notion, inter alia, an in-depth critical analysis of the referenced strategies and development plans. Unfortunately, the author failed in this regard as well.

    Fourthly, the author is discernibly confused and/or completely oblivious about what constitute a budget.  In fact, it might very well be that the author hasn’t even taken the time to read, much less to study the budget properly, with a view to comprehend and absorb its contents, structure, and the overarching framework. To this end, the author contends that… the budget has no clear structure that points to medium or long-term certainty… no clear policy statements to indicate that the budgets are linked to indexed values”. Here, the author displayed an elementary philosophical and theoretical error, misunderstanding, misinterpretation, misconception, and misapplication of a basic “terminology”. In this respect, there is no such thing as “medium or long-term certainty”, within a realistic and pragmatic context of how economies actually work. There is, however, medium to long term “predictability”, which is very different from certainty. 

    Fifthly, the national budgets do contain policy statements and targets. These can be found, not in the budget speech, but in Volume No.2 of the budget estimates. The policy statements include the objectives, strategies, impact, and indicators for the fiscal year. So, undoubtedly the author did not study the budget together with the accompanying estimates thoroughly, or perhaps, at all.

    As evidently demonstrated herein, the author has failed miserably on several fronts to robustly justify his contentions within the framework of an empirical analysis. Therefore, the author’s essays cannot be taken seriously as any sort of critical analysis. 

    In a Part II to this article, the other aspects of the aforenamed author’s contentions in parts 3 & 4 of his series, will be addressed frontally.

     

    Featured Top Right
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Joel Bhagwandin
    Joel Bhagwandin

    Related Posts

    Do Guyanese truly want to vote for these Opposition Presidential Candidates — Aubrey Norton, Nigel Hughes, Amanza Walton-Desir, and Azruddin Mohamed — None presents a real vision, a concrete economic plan, or a sense of national unity. What they offer is a Coalition of Chaos — built on race-baiting, fraud, and political irrelevance.

    NONSENSE THAT PPP CALLED ELECTIONS EARLY GIVING THEMSELVES UNFAIR ADVANTAGE

    The PNCR and the women in the party

    E-25 – INTERNATIONALLY-RESPECTED VS SANCTIONED/NO TRACK-RECORD CANDIDATES

    OPEN CHALLENGE FOR AZRUDIN MOHAMED – GO TO THE USA IF YOU DARE

    Fractured Opposition Parties, Flawed Ambitions: Why PNC AFC, and Forward Guyana Are Destined to Fail Due to Greed and Chaos. The opposition parties are in complete turmoil and disarray. Their members are leaving in droves for the PPP party, while some are desperately trying to form splinter groups to take advantage of the 29.1% Afro-Guyanese community. Azruddin Mohamed — a disgraced money launderer, gold smuggler, and fraudster — has been entirely shunned by his Muslim community. Now, he seeks to con the Amerindian community with gifts and cash. If these so-called leaders cannot even manage their own parties, how can they be trusted to govern an entire nation?

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    What do you make of it? by Leonard Craig

    November 18, 2024744K Views

    President Irfaan Ali Emphasises Discipline and Accountability Over Project Delays

    November 13, 2024566K Views

    The Hollow Ambitions of Nigel Hughes: A Political Opportunist and Exhibitionist with Empty Promises.

    July 11, 2024100K Views
    Don't Miss

    Do Guyanese truly want to vote for these Opposition Presidential Candidates — Aubrey Norton, Nigel Hughes, Amanza Walton-Desir, and Azruddin Mohamed — None presents a real vision, a concrete economic plan, or a sense of national unity. What they offer is a Coalition of Chaos — built on race-baiting, fraud, and political irrelevance.

    In the lead-up to the upcoming elections, four opposition figures—Aubrey Norton, Nigel Hughes, Amanza Walton-Desir,…

    NONSENSE THAT PPP CALLED ELECTIONS EARLY GIVING THEMSELVES UNFAIR ADVANTAGE

    June 21, 2025

    The PNCR and the women in the party

    June 21, 2025

    E-25 – INTERNATIONALLY-RESPECTED VS SANCTIONED/NO TRACK-RECORD CANDIDATES

    June 20, 2025
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews
    72

    Over 50 poisoned at wedding in Iraq

    8.9

    EAM Jaishankar Meets Guyanese PM Mark Phillips, Discuss Energy, Disaster Resilience And Defence Cooperation

    Most Popular

    What do you make of it? by Leonard Craig

    November 18, 2024744K Views

    President Irfaan Ali Emphasises Discipline and Accountability Over Project Delays

    November 13, 2024566K Views

    The Hollow Ambitions of Nigel Hughes: A Political Opportunist and Exhibitionist with Empty Promises.

    July 11, 2024100K Views
    Our Picks

    Do Guyanese truly want to vote for these Opposition Presidential Candidates — Aubrey Norton, Nigel Hughes, Amanza Walton-Desir, and Azruddin Mohamed — None presents a real vision, a concrete economic plan, or a sense of national unity. What they offer is a Coalition of Chaos — built on race-baiting, fraud, and political irrelevance.

    June 21, 2025

    NONSENSE THAT PPP CALLED ELECTIONS EARLY GIVING THEMSELVES UNFAIR ADVANTAGE

    June 21, 2025

    The PNCR and the women in the party

    June 21, 2025
    Popular Categories
    • Global News
    • Election Rigging
    • Sports
    • Special News
    Do you want to associate with us
    • Business Opportunities
    • Advertise with us
    • Contact Us
    • www.democracyguyana.com Guyana – London – India

      For more information, contact us.
    DemocracyGuyana.com
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube TikTok
    • Home
    • About DG
    • Become a Member
    • Join as Volunteers
    • Forum
    • Advertise with us
    DG BRANCHES: GUYANA, USA, CANADA, UK, CARIBBEAN, AND INDIA
    © 2025 DemocracyGuyana.com.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.